One of many favorite dishes across all the continents is Pizza. Regardless of geographical location, a lot of people from seniors and adults to teens, to children, enjoy eating a Pizza.
Therefore, starting a pizzeria can be a smart decision. With lots of yummy pizza recipes available, impressing and luring your customers should be easy and quick. However, if you’re looking to start this lucrative business, consider purchasing all the much-needed appliances and utensils in your professional kitchen.
Even if it’s just for yourself and little ones at home, owning the best pizza peel America’s Test Kitchen is most definitely a must-have. With such an array of options available, choosing the right one to suit you perfectly can be tricky.
In this article, we’ve carefully handpicked the top models currently available and discussed factors to consider when making a choice.
What is a pizza peel?
For every pizza enthusiast, the pizza peel is a must-have tool. It helps place your pizza in your oven from the worktop directly without causing any of ingredient to spill off the pizza’s top.
Some people prefer to compare this nifty tool to a giant spatula where you can easily build pizza and then move it to the oven. That’s not all: a pizza peel lets users remove the pizza from the oven to your serving dish while ensuring that your fingers don’t get burnt in the process.
Reviews of Americas Test Kitchen Pizza Peel
Here are top rated Pizza Peel consumer reports on the market today
1 – New Star Foodservice 50219 Aluminum Pizza Peel
Our top choice is New Star Foodservice 50219 Aluminum Pizza Peel offering the best of wood and aluminum. This model features aluminum since it’s cost-effective compared to its counterpart. Plus, they don’t require seasoning or absorb food particles and unwanted odors.
This pizza peel is made of durable aluminum to ensure long-lasting use. New Star Foodservice 50219 Aluminum Pizza Peel features a large blade to ensure it accommodates any pizza size you want to bake, even up to extra-large size. This large aluminum blade will help save time and balance pizza while loading and unloading.
More so, it has an easy-grip handle to ensure users safely load and unload their pizzas, while offering optimal control and keeping your hands safe from oven’s heat. Plus, it features triple rivets for a more reliable connection between the blade and handles.
- Durable anodized aluminum
- Natural solid wood handle
- Tapered edge design
- Large metal surface
- Aluminum and wood construction
- Unfinished handle
Top 2 – EXO Non-Stick Super Peel Pro Composite: Americas Test Kitchen Best Pizza Peel
Next on the list is EXO Non-Stick Super Peel Pro Composite, designed to offer a non-stick pizza transfer with ease. This feature ensures low maintenance and long-lasting use.
This goof-proof peel will pick up and transfer the pizza to your stone. EXO Non-Stick Super Peel Pro Composite will not spilt or warp like wood, and it’s totally dishwasher friendly. This composite peel features a naturally low-friction sliding surface, which is NSF approved for food contact.
Thanks to its conveyor technology, this model is easy to pick bread, crusts, and pie with ease and transfer.
- Conveyor belt
- Non-stick performance
- Easy to clean
- Sturdy construction
- Synthetic fabric tends to shrink.
Top 3 – Epicurean Pizza Peel, 17-Inch by 10-Inch
This pizza peel comes with a beveled front edge design responsible for its reversible feature. This 17-inch by 10-inch tool is nonporous, durable, and lightweight. It offers easy and safe use. On top of that, it’s dishwasher safe and knife friendly. However, we won’t advise using the Epicurean Pizza Peel as a cutting board.
Furthermore, this product is made in the USA and temperature resistant up to 350 degrees F. More so, its built-in hole features ensure this unit is easy to grab, use and store.
- Available in two different colors and size options
- Lightweight and durable
- Dishwasher safe and knife friendly
- Good size
- Odor sticks
Top 4 – Checkeredchef Stainless Steel Pizza Peel
If you hate dealing with dropped pies or burned arm, then Checkeredchef Stainless Steel Pizza Peel is a smart buy. It features a thin, stainless steel paddle designed to easily slip under pies and pizzas, unlike thick wooden models.
This model works great with a grill or oven. This model is an excellent choice for outdoor and indoor pizza ovens, and also serves as an extra-large turner for BBQ. This brilliant pizza lifter or flipper works amazingly for adding and removing pizza from and to your pizza stone or pizza steel. More importantly, this unit comes in handy as a bakers peel to help lift tarts, pies, and cakes.
What’s more? This model comes with a folding handle to ensure easy storage. Checkeredchef Stainless Steel Pizza Peel is compact and features a black rubber handle for a comfortable grip. Its wooden handles won’t splinter or scratch. Besides, it’s constructed using stainless steel, which is also dishwasher friendly.
- Compact design
- Stainless steel construction
- Wooden handles for safe use.
- Dishwasher friendly
- Not a very larger peel
Top 5 – Pizza Royale Bamboo Pizza Peel: Best Wood for Pizza Peel
Pizza Royale Ethically Sourced Premium Natural Bamboo Pizza Peel allows you to place and remove the bread and other baking products directly from and to your oven. This product also doubles as a cheese, bread, and cutting board. Also, it works well as a serving block, which shows its high versatility level.
Further, it comes in a lightweight and sturdy design. Pizza Royale Ethically Sourced Premium Natural Bamboo Pizza Peel features a contoured design handle to make baking and food preparation fun and straightforward.
If properly cared for, then this model won’t warp, crack, or split. Unlike cheap products, this unit will protect your fingers from splinters. Plus, it’s easy to clean; all you have to do is hand wash with warm water.
That’s not all: this model is backed by a 180-day guarantee, which shows the manufacturer’s high level of confidence in this product.
- No cracking, warping or splitting
- 180-day guarantee
- Easy-grip handle
- Impressive versatility
- The handle could be sturdier
Top 6 – TDHDIKE Premium Aluminum Pizza Peel: Best Pizza Peel for Home Use
Another option earning a spot on our list is TDHDIKE Premium Aluminum Pizza Peel with its high-quality commercial-grade aluminum. Speaking about its construction, this model features an all-natural oak wood handle with leather rope for high-grade and impressive durability.
This unit offers a wide range of applications, allowing users to transfer bread, pizzas, and other baked goods from and to the oven. TDHDIKE Premium Aluminum Pizza Peel is compatible with most commercial pizza accessories and ovens.
Also, it features a foldable design to ensure easy storage. This unit has no troubles fitting in any corner of your bakery, gourmet pizza parlor, and kitchen. More so, it’s accompanied by a 100% money-back guarantee to offer users peace of mind.
- Wide application
- Foldable design for easy storage
- Made of high-quality commercial grade aluminum
- Thin construction
- Pizza tends to slide off easily
Top 7 – American Metalcraft 3512 35.5″ Aluminum Pizza Peel
Making it to our list is American Metalcraft 3512 35.5″ Aluminum Pizza Peel. This model allows pizzas to slide out easily. Its 14 gauge aluminum blade and 19-inch wooden handle bring extreme safety and comfortable grip.
Further, it features a lightweight construction to ensure cleaning and use is a breeze. Plus, it doubles as a serving tool to offer an authentic and more rustic presentation.
- Available in different handle length
- Lightweight construction
- Easy slide out
- Craftsmanship could be better.
Top 8 – EXO Non-Stick Super Peel Pizza Peel: Americas Test Kitchen Pizza Peel
This model is another highly-rated pizza peel requiring less maintenance. This model features a food-safe polymer seal coat to ensure you can lift and transfer pie crusts, pastry dough, cake layers, pizza, etc. easily. In addition, it’s made in the USA to offer peace of mind.
- 100% made in the USA
- Non-stick pizza peel
- Unmatched customer service
- Might require much cornmeal
Things to Consider When Purchasing a Pizza Peel
Pizza peel wood vs. metal? different
This nifty tool is made of mainly two materials – metal or wood. However, there are models offering the best of both worlds.
Obviously, these materials will definitely have their advantages and disadvantages. Nonetheless, with simple rules, you can easily surpass some of them.
Let’s a quick look at these materials:
Wooden Pizza Peel
When it comes to ease of use, wooden pizza peel makes a good buy. But, maintaining this option can be challenging. One of the main advantages of using a wooden pizza peel is its non-stick feature, which means it eliminates the hassle of raw pizza sticking to the peel.
If you’re anything like me, sometimes forgetting to put flour or cornmeal on the peel before placing the pizza, then the wooden pizza peel might be your best bet.
Unlike the metal pizza peels, these models are more appealing, which is why most people purchase them without being aware of its advantages or disadvantages. Sadly, this material has its flaws.
Wood peels are thick, which means rotating the pizza while baking can be a bit difficult. Moreover, they are challenging to maintain and tend to absorb food odor. Thus, it’s important to air dry after washing, and not use the peel as a cutting board to ensure long-lasting performance.
You should also opt for models made of high-quality wood, which ensures that the peel won’t crack or even split easily. This will save you from accidents that result in a lot of mess while trying to get the raw pizza into your oven.
Metal Pizza Peel
This variant is usually made out of stainless steel or aluminum. If owning a pizza peel that lasts longer is a priority, you will lean towards the stainless steel. Their thin design allows users to rotate them with ease during the baking process.
More so, these models are long-lasting and easy to clean. They do not require air drying, no odors, and no stains, which means maintenance is a breeze. However, its construction offers a disadvantage. Raw pizza dough and metal surfaces tend to stick, which means the longer your dough stays on the peels, the trickier it’s to slide off the nifty tool.
Also, the pizza peel surface should be coated with flour or cornmeal before placing your raw pizza on the metal surface to ensure a non-stick experience.
When it comes to peel’s shape, there are two types: square-headed and rounded pizza peel. Most professionals prefer rounded peels to ensure easy pizza maneuvering and a small doorway. But if you’ve got a small grill or oven, then the square-headed models for more practical use.
The pizza peels are available in a wide range of sizes. They come with an array of the paddle’s size and total length. This is a major factor, especially for people with less space for kitchen utensils and tools.
The size of the peel varies from 12-inch to 16-inch. Pinning down the right peel’s size depends on your oven’s size. For beginners, it’s advisable to go for smaller models (at least 12-inch). With around 14-inch pizza peel, you can easily handle the tool and rotate easily during the baking process. Plus, it ensures you don’t spill the pizza while transferring.
Also, if you don’t like exposing your hands to a very hot oven, then you should consider a medium-size handle peel. The medium size makes a decent choice since the handle won’t be too big, rotating the pizza while baking will be much easier.
Even better, you can consider models with a wooden handle, which ensures you don’t get burnt while baking.
What is the best pizza peel
When it comes to pizza peels, our top pick is New Star Foodservice 50219 Aluminum Pizza Peel. However, we’ve discussed other best options to suit your needs.