It’s safe to say that nearly everyone will include pizza in their list of favorite foods – either young or old. While restaurants offer delectable pizza, baking one at home offers a lot of benefits. Homemade pizzas are comparatively cheaper and allow health-conscious individuals to decide how nutritious and tasty they will be for a healthy, mouth-watering pizza.
To achieve this, there are a couple of must-have tools, including a pizza pan. The pan can influence the type of pizza you can bake and the size. Therefore, it’s vital to opt for the right one.
Homemade pizza may be dulcet, but struggling to find the perfect cookware from the hundreds of sale options can be a daunting experience. Thus, we’ve carefully handpicked the top 7 best pizza pans america’s test kitchen to suit your needs, regardless of who you’re – grill or oven person.
America’s Test Kitchen Review of Pan Pizza
Here are top rated pizza pan of 2021
#1 – Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Pizza Pan
The Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan has a 14-inch diameter and is made from cast iron, which means this unit offers enough baking space and durability to serve you for many decades.
The manufacturer was so sure of the pan’s quality that they offer a limited lifetime warranty. This pan heats up quickly. It attains 400 degrees F in about 4 minutes on medium heat. This fast-heating pan will withstand high temperatures. However, at high temperatures above 650 degrees, you might be at risk of burning off the seasonings.
Also, Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan has a slow cooldown process, which is an ideal feature for a baking pan. Plus, it helps save a lot of time, since you can replace the pizza dough without having to worry about heat loss.
Furthermore, this unit has even heat distribution, ensuring that your pizza is uniformly and adequately cooked. And, it’s compatible with any cooker, including a grill and oven. Even better, Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan is a multifunctional one, allowing you to do more with it than just making pizza on any stove type: fireplace grates, induction, stovetop, etc.
- Sturdy cast iron construction
- Durable pan
- Grill and oven use
- Speedy heat up
- Withstand high temperature
- Pre-seasoning not required
#2 – Home-Complete Cast Iron Pizza Pan Skillet
Another 14-inch pan making it to our list is the Home-Complete Cast Iron Pizza Pan. This model has an ample baking space, which is big enough for making larger pizzas. This unit has an impressive heat-up time and excellent heat retention.
This model features handles for easy lifting and carrying. More so, the manufacturer included a small lip to prevent food from spilling. Home-Complete Cast Iron Pizza Pan comes pre seasoned with a vegetable oil formula for a nonstick baking space. However, some customers complained of the food being stuck to the pan sometimes.
But with a little seasoning before use, this pan won’t disappoint. Also, ensure that you add a thin oil coating after each use to season the pan; thereby, protecting it against rust. Similarly, this unit is compatible with your grill or oven, and with other kinds of stove to bake pastries, sear meat, grill veggies, and meats, etc.
Equally important, the Home-Complete Cast Iron Pizza Pan comes with a reasonable price tag with a decent 10-year limited warranty to sweeten the deal.
- Grill, oven, and stovetop use
- Easy to clean
- Sturdy cast iron material
- 10-year limited warranty
- Multipurpose design
- Not very stable on stovetops
#3 – Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Nonstick Bakeware 14-Inch Sheet Pizza Pan
This is arguably the best pizza pan for the crispy crust you can purchase. This pan comes from Cuisinart, one of the top cookware, bakeware, and kitchen appliance manufacturing brands. If you need a pan with holes, then Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Nonstick Bakeware 14-Inch Pizza Pan is the best choice.
This product is designed to serve you for many years without rusting or deforming. It has a diameter of 14 inches and perforated to allow users to bake crispy crust pizza. 14-Inch Pizza Pan is made of heavy gauge steel aluminized for optimal even heating.
That’s not all: it is backed by a lifetime warranty, which shows the manufacturer’s high confidence level in this pizza pan. Furthermore, this model is totally dishwasher safe for a convenient cleaning experience. In addition, this bakeware features thick rolled edges to prevent wrapping at temperatures above 700 degrees F.
- Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning
- Perforated surface delivers optimal baking efficiency.
- Nonstick baking surface
- Heavy-gauge aluminum construction
- The coating tends to deform after prolonged use.
#4 – Victoria Cast Iron Pizza Crepe Pan
The Victoria Cast Iron Pizza Crepe Pan is another large pan made of cast iron. This unit features top-notch engineering with loop handles for easier handling and better leverage. It offers a wider baking space with its 15–inch diameter to accommodate large pizza dough.
Even better, this bakeware is preseasoned using 100% non-GMO flaxseed oil at high temperatures to offer excellent easy food release. The best part, it gets better with time. In terms of versatility, this pizza pan is ideal for baking delectable cookies or pizza, fry bacon or eggs, make roti, Dosa, pancakes, also grill, roast, or broil meats and veggies.
In addition, this model works well with all kitchens; grill, camping, oven, induction, electric, gas, etc. best of all: the manufacturer sweetens the deal with a lifetime warranty, which assures customers that this model won’t rust and deliver excellent heat retention.
- Beautiful design
- High heat retention
- Uniform heat distribution
- Comes pre seasoned and gets better with time
- Might require reseasoning for the best nonstick performance
#5 – Best Deep Dish Pizza Pan Kitchenware
If you’re in the market for bakeware for making dulcet Detroit-style pizza this weekend, you can’t really go wrong purchasing LloydPans Kitchenware 8 by 10 inch Detroit Style Pizza Pan. This rectangular pan is made of heavy-duty anodized aluminum and rocks the brand’s exclusive Dura-Kote finish to deliver a rust-free quality baking surface without having to preseason it.
Its premium finish works as a nonstick, non-toxic, and permanent coating, making both the baking and cleaning process a snap. More so, LloydPans Kitchenware Detroit Style Pizza Pan is heat safe up to 700 degrees F and delivers that much desired crispy crust.
What’s more? This unit has a 2.5-inch depth, making it suitable for making fluffy, buttery, and mouth-watering Detroit-style pizza with a crispy crust. Keep in mind that this model can only make pizza for a small-sized gathering like a small family reunion or picnic. \
Unlike other pans, LloydPans Kitchenware Detroit Style Pizza Pan is metal utensil safe. Besides, it features a slightly sloped side to ensure emptying the content is hassle-free as well as storing this pan.
- Rectangular shape
- Made of heavy-duty anodized aluminum
- Slightly slope edges
- Features Dura-Kote finishes for impressive non stick performance.
- Durable construction and heat safe up to 700 degrees F.
- Poor quality control
#6 – American Metalcraft TP20 Tp Pan
For those who want to cook finger-licking pizzas, the American Metalcraft TP20 Tp Pan is another decent choice. This high durable pizza pan featured a silver color and made of 18-gauge heavy-duty aluminum.
This pan is a must-have tool for pizza enthusiasts. When you intend to use this pizza pan at a restaurant or home, it delivers outstanding performance for easy, efficient baking sessions. American Metalcraft TP20 Tp Pan is designed with the intent of making cooking effortless.
This reliable pan features a sturdy metal construction that ensures your pizza is evenly cooked while eliminating any hot spots. This unit is available in different sizes from 6-inch to 20-inch to ensure everyone finds the right size pizza pan.
Another incredible feature of this pizza pan is its elevated edge, which keeps the pizzas in the middle position. Also, it allows you to make both large and extra-large pizzas with ease. For a reliable and durable pan that delivers unbeatable performance, this is the right way to go.
- Available in different sizes
- Ideal for both home and restaurant use
- Easy to use
- Attractive design
- No handles
- This model requires handwash.
#7 – G & S Pizza Pan
The G & S Metal Products Company ProBake Teflon Nonstick Pizza Pan is another highly durable pan on our list with steel construction. This product delivers unbeatable uniform heat distribution to create crispy pizza crust with ease.
On top of that, it sports Telfon Xtra nonstick coating for scratch-free surface and easy cleaning. Plus, it’s metal utensil safe, which means you can use your pizza slicing tool to cut the pizza right on the pan. This way, baking and serving your pizza seems effortless.
Additionally, its Teflon Xtra nonstick coating gets rid of the need to spray oil before using for easy food release. This roomy pan should be enough for 6 servings. Plus, it has raised edges, which offer a firm grip and prevent spillage.
- Even heat distribution
- Made of steel
- Raised edges for a firm grip
- Teflon Xtra nonstick coating for quick food release
- Metal utensil safe
- At high heat, this roomy pan tends to wrap
#8 – USA Pan Bakeware Steel Pizza Pan
This USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel Pizza Pan is one of the best options for making restaurant-style pizza. It’s crafted using aluminized steel to deliver high performance and durability.
Coming with a distinctive fluted design, this pizza pan has incredible airflow and even heat distribution. Plus, its unique looks improve your kitchen decor. Furthermore, this pan is easy to clean, thanks to its Americoat plus silicone nonstick coating, ensuring quick food release.l
- Highly reliable and durable pan
- Fluted baking surface for excellent performance
- high-quality silicone nonstick coating
- Easy to clean
- The nonstick coating isn’t very durable
# 9 – T-fal Airbake Nonstick Pizza Pan
The T-fal Airbake Nonstick Pizza Pan is a go-to for people looking to make a crisper crust. It is made of two aluminum sheets, which makes this unit lightweight and an excellent heat conductor. Plus, its aluminum property improves this pan is durable and rust-free.
What’s more? The bottom sheet prevents the pizza crust from burning by acting like a heat shield blocking direct oven heat. Also, its perforated design ensures even heat distribution and better airflow.
- Wrap-free design
- Nonstick coating
- Uniform heat distribution
- Built to keep your crust from burnt
- Best used to make thin pizza.
What should I look for when buying the best pizza pan
The bigger the pizza pan, the bigger the pizza it makes. However, it’s better to opt for a slightly bigger pan to ensure your pizza crust stays in the middle of the pan for even cooking. However, it would be best if you did not buy a much bigger pan than your pizza size, as it’ll take time to heat and cook.
For crisper pizzas, you want to purchase a lightweight pizza pan. It takes less time to heat up but requires extra care to avoid burning your pizza. Also, they make soft pizza that takes a while to chew. Nonetheless, you should pick a weight that suits your needs.
The common materials used for constructing pizza pans are aluminized steel, aluminum, and cast iron. Different materials offer a unique feature, which makes it an advantage over the other. For instance, aluminized steel and aluminum have a fast cook time.
What’s the shape of a pizza pan?
Pizza pan comes in different shape based on the type of pizza you want to make
What’s the best pizza pan to buy?
Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan is the best pizza pan that we recommend considering its impressive heat distribution and retention.
We’ve reviewed the top 9 best pizza pans. However, it’s up to you to decide which pizza pan suits your baking needs. But if you still have trouble choosing a pan, check out our buying guide on how to make an informed decision.