When it comes to making pizza at home, nothing beats a homemade pizza sauce. Making your pizza sauce using vegetables and tomatoes is an undeniable pleasant experience.
Unfortunately, we barely have enough time to eat in this fast-paced world, let alone spend quality hours prepping your vegetables for pizza. But with canned pizza sauce, you get everything you need and ready for a fancy dinner with your spouse, family, or alone.
However, there are different options on sale, from good to great, which makes picking the right one slightly challenging. Let’s consider the top 10 best canned & jarred pizza sauce to buy for a delectable dinner without further ado.
Reviews of Best Canned & Jarred Sauce ATK 2020
Here are top rated best canned & jarred sauce by consumer reports
#1 – Don Pepino Pizza Sauce
Coming top on our list is Don Pepino Pizza Sauce. This pizza sauce contains pure corn oil, garlic, salt, fresh vine-ripened tomatoes, and spices. The manufacturer opts for a safe, healthy oil to boost heart performance and lower your heart disease chances.
Not only that, Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is touted to be cholesterol-free, which is an ideal choice for health-conscious individuals. Also, this top-pick sauce does not include filters, artificial color, added sugar, gums, starches, preservatives, and citric acid. This way, you are assured of a healthy meal with your family.
For those who prefer the milder sauce to allow you to experiment with a wider range of toppings, this is the right unit to opt for. However, Don Pepino Pizza Sauce might not be the best choice for people looking for a more spicy and flavourful sauce, except you are looking to spicy the sauce to your taste before putting it on your pizza.
There is 120mg of sodium, 3g of sugar, 35 calories, and no cholesterol for guilt-free and healthy options for a quarter cup.
- Cholesterol free
- Does not contain preservatives, starches, fillers, artificial color, citric acid, added sugars, or gums
- Not so spicy for impressive versatility
- Primarily made of corn oil for lessening heart diseases.
- Not an ideal option for people looking for a spicy sauces
#2 – Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce
Next on our list of the best pizza sauce is from Muir Glen. This sauce contains garlic, basil, black pepper, organic extra virgin olive oil, sea salt, tomatoes, onions, and organ. This simple ingredient combination offers a more traditional and versatile flavor.
This model makes use of only organic tomatoes sourced in California. This sauce is verified by the non-GMO Project and certified by USDA. People are particularly conscious of what they eat. Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce is made using ingredients from organic and ethical farming.
Even better, the carefully handpicked tomatoes offer the peak of flavor and bring a bold, bright flavor to your pizza. This canned pizza sauce is easy to use. Also, it flavors your pizza with spices and several Italian herbs. Plus, the extra-virgin olive oil delivers a delectable taste.
- Sugar-free sauce
- Organic and versatile
- non-GMO and USDA Certified tomatoes
- Traditional flavor to allow using several types of toppings
- Requires users to add ingredients for a unique flavor
#3 – Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef
For pizza enthusiasts who prefer to have a sauce close to your homemade one, then Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef is the way to go. This is arguably the best canned pizza with spicy and sweetish flavors. This unit has a smooth yet thick texture that spreads easily and evenly rough the pizza dough.
This sauce features an olive oil base, which is a decent choice for people who want healthy and lighter oil. Pastorelli Pizza Sauce includes cheese to enhance its flavor presented along with traditional seasoning and spice.
Aside from its sweet taste, this sauce is BPA-free and doesn’t include gluten, preservatives, and corn syrup. In addition, it’s an award-winning sauce with almost a half-decade of experience in this space. Keep in mind that this canned sauce contains some common allergens because of the sauce’s cheese.
- Low in salt, sugar, and calories
- Easy to use
- Gluten-free and BPA-free can
- Supports different toppings types
- The sauce contains milk and is not ideal for vegans or people intolerant to lactose.
#4 – Botticelli Premium Italian Pizza Sauce
If you love to have Italian pizza in your home’s comfort, the Botticelli Premium Italian Pizza Sauce is the right way to go. This canned sauce brings rich, lively, and aromatic flavor to your own homemade pizza dough.
Like most models out there, this jarred pizza sauce features fresh Italian tomato, onions, sea salt, carrots, extra virgin olive oil, oregano, and garlic for a real authentic flavor. It’s ready to use and brings great tomato taste to any pizza dough.
Further, this unit allows you to indulge without worries about sugar and carbs for a healthy diet. Even better, it’s delivered in a well-sealed high-quality glass jar to keep its freshness until it’s ready for use.
- Authentic tomato flavor
- Ready to use pizza sauce
- Well-sealed high-quality glass jar
- Low-sugar and low-carb
- A bit of tangy flavor that might not work well with you
#5 – Rao’s Homemade All Natural Pizza Sauce
This is actually a marinara sauce, but also ideal for pizza. A full jar is enough for 8 servings. This unit contains basil to enhance the texture and aroma of this sauce. It has a wide variety of tomato sauce to suit your taste.
More importantly, it provides a fresher taste with a perfect balance of basil, tomatoes, and fruity olive oil. Rao’s Homemade All Natural Pizza Sauce contains only natural grown tomatoes and delivers that mouth-watering Italian flavor.
The tomatoes bring a brighter and bold flavor to any pizza dough. Also, it contains sugar to balance the salt for a sauce with the perfect balance of textures and flavors.
- Rich, smooth flavor
- Closeable jar design
- Tomato flavor isn’t overwhelming.
- Its less tomato flavor might be unsuitable for some
#6 – Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef
The Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef packs a punch in terms of flavor without being overly overpowering. This option doubles as a dipping sauce, which makes it an ideal choice for family dinner to eat with much love at the same time.
You can use the Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef with your homemade dough or with the makers’ crust for delectable results. This sauce has an incredible balance between acidity and sweetness from vinegar and tomatoes.
This means this sauce is not overly sweet and can be a deal-breaker for pizza lovers looking for sweet pizza. But if you’re down for savory sauces, then you don’t need to look anywhere else.
- California tomatoes
- Ideal for lightly sauced pizzas
- Rich, intriguing flavor
- Includes sugar
- The can might not be BPA free
#7 – Don Pepino Original Pizza Sauce
To start with, nothing rivals the convenience of using a well-prepared pizza sauce. Its freshness and flavor of this sauce is similar to your family recipe, which is a decent alternative to making your sauce from scratch.
The sauce offers your pizza dough with rich texture, which means you get more than good taste but also a thin layer. Don Pepino Original Pizza Sauce covers the whole dough before the cheese goes on it.
The low-price and easy-open lid make Don Pepino Original Pizza Sauce an excellent choice for anyone looking to purchase a budget-option pizza sauce offering incredible convenience.
- No added sugar
- Thick, chunky sauce
- Classic recipe
- Made with corn oil
#8 – Pizzaiolo Pizza Sauce Autentico No. 10 Can
The Pizzaiolo Pizza Sauce is another canned one fully prepared with herbs, garlic, and extra-virgin oil. It’s perfectly blended with fresh red-ripe tomatoes to add a flavorful sensation to any palette.
Further, it’s more of a traditional-styled sauce using ancient processing methods, making it a rival to your homemade pizza sauce. This unit is available in different packs options so that everyone can enjoy its perfect mix of crushed tomatoes and various spices.
- Similar to homemade pizza
- Wide range of pack options
- Traditional style sauce
- Several sauces included
- Not very thick
#9 – Stanislaus Full Red Fully Prepared Pizza Sauce
The Stanislaus Full Red Fully Prepared Pizza Sauce is made with California grown tomato. The manufacturer ensures that only the best quality of tomatoes are used to make high-quality Italian-style tomatoes sauces.
Even better, it has a smooth pizza sauce that’s seasoned mildly with great consistency and seasoned. This model makes it easier to add spread this sauce to the homemade pizza right out of the can.
- Several pack sizes
- Stanislaus tomato sauce
- Ideal for food trucks, vendors, and home kitchen
- Contains a lot of oil
#10 – Boboli Traditional Italian PIZZA SAUCE
Boboli Traditional Italian PIZZA SAUCE is flavored with onion and garlic for a perfect Italian-style delectable pizza. This is an ideal choice for topping a 12-inch pizza.
Even better, this product mixes spices and garlic for a yummy tasty sauce. All you’ve to do is spread the sauce over the pizza dough and add your tops and favorite cheese.
- Rich blend of ingredients
- Tasty sauce
- Three sauce packets in each box
- Need to buy more than one
How to Choose the Right Canned & Jarred Pizza Sauce
Homemade pizza sauce’s taste has no rival, but it takes a while to make. This is where purchasing a jarred or canned store-bought pizza sauce.
While trying to pin down the best pizza sauce, you need to consider a couple of factors before making a choice:
It’s best to go for a thick sauce, so most people prefer marinara sauce to the regular pizza sauce. If you opt for a watery texture sauce, then the pizza dough gets soggy and, therefore, leaves you with a bad tasting, undercooked pizza.
The sauce should also have a plain thick texture and not include lots of chunks of tomato, herbs, or other vegetables.
Your pizza preference
You need to know the type of pizza you intend to make at home before purchasing a can pizza sauce. A New York Style pizza has a thin crust, while the Chicago style pizza features a deep dish.
The pizza sauce of your choice should be based on the pizza style and its toppings. It’s advisable for those who want an authentic pizza taste to opt for well-spiced pizza sauce.
Some sauces might be too spicy, and your kids might not like it. Generally speaking, they prefer little sweet and mild spicy flavored pizzas. So, it’s best to check the sauce’s spiciness if you intend to cook for your kids.
Some brands include vegetables, which makes the sauces nutritious. Also, it allows your kids to eat the veggies without knowing. Also, the veggies make your pizza very tasty. Vegetables like basil add flavor and aromatic taste to your pizza.
- Difference between pizza sauce and spaghetti sauce
Pizza sauce is an uncooked tomato sauce, while spaghetti sauce is slow-simmered. The formal usually contain a couple of herbs such as basil, bay leaf, etc.
Best pizza sauce brands
There are more than a dozen brands out there; however, it’s essential to purchase your sauce from only reputable brands, ensuring safe consumption.
Thus, we recommend that you only purchase canned pizza sauce from any of the following brands: Mutti, Prego, Rao’s Homemade, Botticelli, Ragu, Chef Boyardee, Pastorelli, Muir Glen, Don Pepino, and many more.
In this fast-paced world, it’s much simpler to prepare meals, but pizza can still pose some challenges considering that there are many things to consider while preparing it. But with our review on the best canned pizza sauce, you should have no issues choosing the right sauce for a simpler pizza-making process. You aslo can check out best pizza Accessory & Tool
But if you still have trouble deciding which canned sauce to purchase, check out our buying guide section to ensure you make an informed decision.