When it comes to toasters, you’ll notice right away that there is a wide range of options available. With 4-slice and 2-slice toasters, metal and plastic picks, including long slots, trying to choose the right model can feel overwhelming.
To ensure that you find the best 2 slice toaster that offers the right settings for your lifestyle, we’ve compared the top 9 incredible appliances on the market for a much smarter decision.
Reviews of Best 2 Slice Toaster Consumer Reports
Here are top rated 2 Slice Toaster on the market today.
Top 1 – Cuisinart CPT-160P1 Metal Classic 2-Slice Toaster
Our top choice, Cuisinart CPT-160P1 Metal Classic 2-Slice Toaster, brings to any kitchen powerful performance and classical beauty. Its unique blend of black painted steel and stainless steel makes this unit a go-to for people sought after classical culinary design.
This compact kitchen appliance delivers incredible performance with several powerful features such as defrost, bagel and reheat functions. Not only that, it includes a removable crumb tray to ensure clean up is a breeze.
What’s more? This unit has a cord wrap underneath the device to keep your countertop looking organized while not in use. Further, it has a bagel function that heats the upper half for a soft, chewy bottom and a crispy top.
But, if for both crispy sides, then you don’t need to engage this function button. Its shade control setting provides a wide range of browning options for perfect toast customization, from 1 – 6 (lightest to darkest).
That’s not all: its multiple toasting function allows you toast, bagel, defrost and reheat your bread. Also, it includes a cancel function to stop all toasting processes at the time. Cuisinart CPT-160P1 Metal Classic 2-Slice Toaster has a wide toaster slot to let you toast a wide variety of items, including sliced bread, french toast, toaster pastries, frozen pancakes, and bagels.
- High lift level
- Multiple functions
- A wide range of shade settings
- Extra-wide slots
- Might not make dark brown toast
Top 2 – Hamilton Beach Keep Warm 2 Slice Toaster
Our runner up is Hamilton Beach Keep Warm 2 Slice Toaster with extra-wide slots to ensure this unit is very accommodating. This model is ideal for toasting bagels and thick-sliced breads.
In addition, this model comes with an optional Keep Warm function, which keeps your toast warm for three minutes without over-toasting. Further, it includes special buttons for the Defrost and Bagel function.
The bagel setting allows you to toast only one side of the sliced bread and the Defrost for toasting or thawing frozen bread. Thanks to its cool walls, Hamilton Beach Keep Warm 2 Slice Toaster does get hot on the outside and includes a high lift lever to retrieve your food from the toaster hassle-free.
What’s more? It has an attractive stainless steel toaster featuring illuminated buttons and a cord wrap at the unit’s base for easy view and clutter-free storage. Like any best 2 slice toaster, there’s a shade selector to allow users to customize their toast brownness.
- Extra-wide slots
- Attractive stainless steel
- Cool touch design
- Toast boost for easy food retrieval
- Could be more durable
Top 3 – KRUPS KH732D50 2-Slice Stainless Steel Toaster
For those looking to give their breakfast an upgrade, the KRUPS KH732D50 2-Slice Toaster might be the right tool for you. This model is equipped with several features for unbeatable customization.
Moving on, this kitchen appliance features a high lift lever to allow users to remove your bagel or toast without hurting yourself. The rotating knob has six browning levels for perfectly even and precise browning results covering the entire slice.
Another interesting thing about KRUPS KH732D50 2-Slice Toaster is its 30-second reheat setting, bagel function, and defrost model to provide you with flawless toast. Further, it comes with a removable rear crumb tray to make cleaning a breeze.
This german-made 2 slice toaster features stainless steel construction for durability and designed to support starting your day with a crunchy, golden-brown breakfast.
- High lift level
- Includes exclusive functions
- Accommodate a wide variety of bread
- Six browning levels
- Shows fingerprint and smudge
Top 4 – Cuisinart CPT-420 Touch to Toast Leverless 2-Slice Toaster
Next is Cuisinart CPT-420 2-Slice Toaster with a seamless mix of cutting-edge design and digital technology, which makes it intuitive and versatile. Its perfect blend of elegant design and digital technology brings incredible performance to any home.
As expected, this product packs several handy, powerful features like count down timer, leverless lift, and digital interface. With the included removable crumb tray to catch crumbs or a little piece of bread, this model is hassle-free to clean.
That’s not all: Cuisinart CPT-420 2-Slice Toaster allows you to wrap the cord underneath when not in use for a clutter-free experience. Further, it has a wide range of shade settings from 1 to 7 to allow users to achieve the perfect browning level.
Similarly, this kitchen appliance comes with multiple toasting functions: bagel, defrost, toast, reheat, and cancel. With its extra-wide slots, this unit easily accommodates thin or thick french toasts, bagels, frozen pancakes, and toaster pastries.
- Motorized lift
- Extra-wide slot
- Features a countdown timer
- 7 shade settings
- Toasting can be more even
Top 5 – Oster TSSTTRJBG1 2-Slice Toaster
If you love to start your day with a golden brown, perfectly crisp slice of bread, then Oster TSSTTRJBG1 2-Slice Toaster can be the way to go. This toaster comes with two extra-wide slots to allow the device to accommodate homemade bread, bagels, and more.
Here’s more: its great dual guides support different bread thicknesses and deliver even toasting. Coming with an intuitive dial and user-friendly control panel, this model lets users pick the perfect shade setting and use the Cancel function to stop the toasting process.
It is also equipped with a high rise level to elevate your toast for safe and easy retrieval. This best 2 slice toaster is snappy to clean up with the aid of its removable crumb tray. Besides, it’s equipped with an anti-jamming mechanism to prevent jams. Plus, its timeless appearance will complement any kitchen decor.
- Advanced Toast Technology
- 7 adjustable shade settings
- Easy to clean
- Even toasting
- The bagel setting could be better
Top 6 – KEEMO Toaster 2 Slice, Extra Long Slot
This compact stainless steel toaster comes in a retro style in beautiful color options, which makes it not just a treat to the eyes but also matches any kitchen’s decor without taking much counter space.
More importantly, it’s simple to operate using an easy one-touch LED indicator button, easy-collection cord storage, easy reach high lift lever, and easy clean removable crumb tray. It’s also equipped with an automatic pop-up mechanism for easy food retrieval without burning your fingers.
Furthermore, KEEMO Toaster 2 Slice Toaster has three basic functions: defrost, bagel, and cancel. On top of that, there are six browning settings for perfect customization. Also, it comes with a 1.5-inch slot wide enough to accommodate thick bread, bagels, and other items with ease.
Additionally, this toaster features a food-grade 18/8 stainless steel housing to help make toast faster and cool rapidly. KEEMO made this kitchen appliance easy to clean, rustproof, and durable for years.
- 6 shade settings
- Compact small size
- Extra-wide slots
- Bagel, Defrost, Cancel function
- High-lift lever
- The button’s sound might not be pleasing
Top 7 – Smeg TSF01RDUS 50’s Retro Style Aesthetic 2 Slice Toaster
Next on our list is Smeg TSF01RDUS 50’s Retro 2 Slice Toaster with two extra-wide slots and self-centering racks. Another trick up this unit’s sleeve is its automatic slice pop up to let users reach the toast without burning their fingers.
This model has anti-slip feet to ensure it stays in place while toasting your slice of bread. For the sake of hassle-free cleaning, Smeg TSF01RDUS 50’s Retro Style Aesthetic 2 Slice Toaster features a removable stainless steel crumb tray.
Here’s more: it offers three preset programs: bagel, defrost, reheat, and six browning levels for customized toasting experience. Plus, it’s available in several different color options to pick from to complement your kitchen decor.
- Anti-slip feet
- Six browning levels
- 3 preset programs
- Extra-wide slots
- Poor quality control
Top 8 – BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster
The BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster is an 850-watts model designed to offer faster toasting without compromising impressive golden brown crispy results. It features self-adjusting guides in the slots to foster even toasting.
And, its bold stainless steel accent complements any kitchen decor. Here’s the best part. This unit comes with three functions: cancel, frozen, and bagel.
Not just that, it sports an extra lift to reach your toasts safely. Coupled with its extra-wide toasting slots, BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster easily accommodates thick breads, bagels, and a wide variety of items.
More importantly, this product comes with a drop-down crumb tray to ensure your counter remains clean and smelling fresh. The crumb tray allows you to remove crumbs before they mess or burn your kitchen.
- Cord wrap for mess-free countertop
- Three functions for customization
- Extra-wide toasting slots
- Extra lift for safe reach
- No indicator
Top 9 – Home Gizmo 2-Slice Toaster
The Home Gizmo 2-Slice Toaster features brushed stainless steel to make this device a treat to the eyes. It comes with two extra-wide slots to allow you to toast a wide variety of items.
Also, this kitchen device includes a removable crumb tray to make cleaning a breeze. Not just that, it offers seven browning dials for golden brown, crispy toast. Its cool touch design keeps this unit’s exterior cool for safe use.
- Cool Touch design
- Brushed stainless steel
- Easy to clean
- 7 browning dials
- Flimsy design
Things to Consider When Purchasing a 2 Slice Toaster
Toasters come with different shade settings, which indicate the scale of how your bread will be toasted. This means devices with a higher scale will provide you with more options and higher accuracy shade settings.
Variable width slots
With wide slots, you can easily fit thin and thick slices of bread. Pressing down the level compresses the metal frame to accommodate your slices as it lowers for even toast, regardless of this slice thickness. This feature comes in handy when you want to toast thicker items like bagels.
This feature is called different names like Toast Boast, Lift Power, and many more. High lift helps you reach your toast safely by popping it up higher than their naturally sitting spot.
These kitchen devices include a removable crumb tray concealed around the unit’s base to make it easier to clean by emptying the crumb tray.
Some toasters include accessories like metal racks, warm items such as croissants or rolls. The more accessories a toaster offers, the better your experience with the unit.
A little longer /A bit more
Different names, same function. The ‘A bit more’ allows you to toast bread for a little longer to achieve the desired result before popping.
The Keep warm lowers the toast back into the kitchen appliance and keeps it warm to prevent your food from being cold when you’re ready.
Some 2 slice toasters come with a digital display featuring countdown timer for ease of use.
If you found that toaster that resonates with your toasting preferences and needs, then you should consider placing an order. There are hundreds of models designed to help make your favorite delicacy. However, not every model does a great job.
For those impressed by more than one 2 slice toaster from our list and having trouble making a final decision, the buying guide section should help make the decision process easier.
If it were up to me, the Cuisinart CPT-160P1 Metal Classic 2-Slice Toaster would be the way to go. It is hassle-free to use, easy to pack up, durable, and extra-wide slots to accommodate a wide variety of items.